Russian Verbs of Motion
A user learning Russian asked:
I’m learning verbs of motion and this card seems wrong to me:
Большой автобус трудно вести A big bus is difficult to drive.
Shouldn’t that be водить not вести?
That’s not a motion taking place in time…it’s naming the motion without reference to time so it should be indeterminate / multidirectional shouldn’t it?
The Easy Answer
– действие (вести машину) (изобразительный жест): нет названия
It is also possible to say “водить машину”. When we say “вести машину” we talk about the action in the moment of driving / a single action. When we say “водить машину” we talk about a more abstract skill of being able to drive, driving multidirectionally and iteratively.
The Full Answer
This matter is better explained turning to the ancestors of the modern Russian: Proto-Slavic and Old Church Slavonic (that is way, way back, even to the times before language had a writing system), and here’s why:
Actually, we are not just dealing with two verbs: a more concrete вести & and a more abstract водить. We must look at at least 4 verbs to get the gist of things: вести / водить; везти / возить.
At first, let’s look at the definitions of each word in the modern Russian:
вести (from Proto-Slavic *vedti or *vesti, Old Church Slavonic вести), currently has about 11 definitions, mostly described as “to lead / to conduct” (e.g. вести собрание). Due to an abundance of definitions also has a few common expressions, one of which is “вести машину”, to drive.
водить (from Proto-Slavic *vedti or *vesti / *voditi, Old Church Slavonic вести / водити), currently has 3 definitions, and a few common expressions. Mainly describes “facilitating a movement of somebody / something”, plus the same action(s) as the verb вести, but more abstractly / iteratively / not in one go (Водить детей на прогулку, водить автомобиль).
везти (from Proto-Slavic *vezti, Old Church Slavonic вести), currently, in its first sense, has 2 definitions, meaning “to carry somebody or something by vehicle” or to deliver (везти детей на автобусе в школу, везти самолетом).
возить (most likely from Proto-Slavic *vezti, Old Church Slavonic вести / возити), currently has 3 definitions, mostly meaning to transport/carry something/somebody by vehicle multidirectionally and iteratively, as opposed to the verb везти (автобус возит нас каждый день).
An attentive learner already noticed that there are two big relatives to all these words: a Proto-Slavic *vesti or *vedti and a Proto-Slavic *vezti. Proto-Slavic language is a reconstructed proto-language of all Slavic languages, so it doesn’t have a writing system, which is why we spell these words with an asterisk.
The Proto-Slavic verb *vedti or *vesti seems to carry the meaning of “leading, conducting”. Notice that the verbs with this anestor possess “leadership qualities”; one needs to “know something” in order to be able to conduct an activity: вести собрание, водить детей на прогулку, водить автомобиль, вести машину. Reconstruction Proto-Slavic/vesti
The Proto-Slavic verb *vezti seems to carry the mearning of “transporting something”. Notice that the verbs with this ancestor reflect either facilitating a transportation of smth/smb, or literally carrying smth/smb by a vehicle: везти детей в школу на автобусе, автобус возит нас каждый день. Reconstruction Proto-Slavic/vezti
In Old Church Slavonic the stem вести starts being associated with both meanings: to lead, and to transport, which, probably eventually brings us to our expression вести машину. Also it might be resonating with the Russian speakers so well because one needs to have certain knowledge in order to drive (read: lead / conduct a car).